What is the Gratuities Clause (GC)?

The Gratuities Clause is a provision that restricts the General Assembly’s power to grant donations, gratuities, or extra compensation to public officers, agents, or contractors after services have been rendered or contracts entered into.

How is gratuity calculated?

Gratuity is typically calculated at 15 days’ wages for each year of completed service, with a maximum limit (e.g., INR 2,000,000 in India)

What is the minimum service period for gratuity eligibility?

Employees must serve a minimum period (usually five years) to be eligible for gratuity

Can an employer arbitrarily forfeit gratuity?

No, employers cannot arbitrarily forfeit gratuity. Legal proceedings and substantial proof are required, and failure to pay gratuity dues can lead to imprisonment

What exceptions exist for gratuity forfeiture?

Exceptions include compensation for innocent crime victims, health insurance plans for retirees, and disability benefits for public safety employees

What is the Gratuities Clause (GC)?

The Gratuities Clause is a provision that restricts the General Assembly’s power to grant donations, gratuities, or extra compensation to public officers, agents, or contractors after services have been rendered or contracts entered into.

How is gratuity calculated?

Gratuity is typically calculated at 15 days’ wages for each year of completed service, with a maximum limit (e.g., INR 2,000,000 in India)

What is the minimum service period for gratuity eligibility?

Employees must serve a minimum period (usually five years) to be eligible for gratuity

Can an employer arbitrarily forfeit gratuity?

No, employers cannot arbitrarily forfeit gratuity. Legal proceedings and substantial proof are required, and failure to pay gratuity dues can lead to imprisonment

What exceptions exist for gratuity forfeiture?

Exceptions include compensation for innocent crime victims, health insurance plans for retirees, and disability benefits for public safety employees

What is the Gratuities Clause (GC)?

The Gratuities Clause is a provision that restricts the General Assembly’s power to grant donations, gratuities, or extra compensation to public officers, agents, or contractors after services have been rendered or contracts entered into.

What is the minimum service period for gratuity eligibility?

Employees must serve a minimum period (usually five years) to be eligible for gratuity

Can an employer arbitrarily forfeit gratuity?

No, employers cannot arbitrarily forfeit gratuity. Legal proceedings and substantial proof are required, and failure to pay gratuity dues can lead to imprisonment

What exceptions exist for gratuity forfeiture?

Exceptions include compensation for innocent crime victims, health insurance plans for retirees, and disability benefits for public safety employees

What is the Gratuities Clause (GC)?

The Gratuities Clause is a provision that restricts the General Assembly’s power to grant donations, gratuities, or extra compensation to public officers, agents, or contractors after services have been rendered or contracts entered into.

What is the minimum service period for gratuity eligibility?

Employees must serve a minimum period (usually five years) to be eligible for gratuity

Can an employer arbitrarily forfeit gratuity?

No, employers cannot arbitrarily forfeit gratuity. Legal proceedings and substantial proof are required, and failure to pay gratuity dues can lead to imprisonment

What exceptions exist for gratuity forfeiture?

Exceptions include compensation for innocent crime victims, health insurance plans for retirees, and disability benefits for public safety employees

Home

Schemes

Services

Community

About Us

Understanding Gratuity Forfeiture: Legal Boundaries and Employee Rights

Neha Gupta

Author

Updated: 28-01-2025 at 6:36 AM

Understanding Gratuity Forfeiture: Legal Boundaries and Employee Rights

Gratuity is a significant financial benefit given to employees as a token of appreciation for their long-term service. However, questions often arise about whether gratuity can be withheld or forfeited if an employee has committed an offence, faced disciplinary actions, or has not vacated employer-provided housing.

According to Indian law, specifically Section 4(6) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, the conditions under which gratuity can be forfeited are very strict. This blog explains these legal boundaries, employee rights, and key case laws that clarify this issue.

Legal Framework For Gratuity Forfeiture

The Payment of Gratuity Act 1972 governs how employers pay gratuities to their workers in India. The act is based on section 4(6) that indicated clearly under which terms a gratuity can be lost by an individual employee.

Willful omission or negligence leading to loss suffered by the employer’s property.
Riotous behaviour, disorderly conduct or any other violent acts demonstrated by an employee.
Any form of moral turpitude committed during employment.

However, this banishment only applies when an employee has been dismissed from services on those grounds. It should be noted that even if the worker is involved in some disciplinary actions or criminal proceedings then he/she cannot be denied his/her entitlements unless sec. 4(6) conditions are met.

Judicial Precedents On Gratuity Forfeiture

Several court rulings have established that gratuity can only be withheld in cases of proven and serious misconduct. This ensures that employers cannot easily deny this benefit without substantial legal grounds.

For instance, it was held by the court in Texmaco Limited v Shri Ram Dhan (1993), that withholding gratuity amount from an employee retiring from service without proven misconduct constitutes unfair labour practice. This highlights the need for concrete evidence before denying gratuity benefits.

In another case titled Brundaban Sahu v. a.s. R.T. Corporation Ltd. (1993), the court held that compulsorily retired employees are still entitled to their gratuity unless there is specific misconduct. The court reinforced that ongoing disciplinary proceedings do not automatically lead to forfeiture of gratuity.

In Gopalkrishna v. Karnataka Soaps & Detergents Ltd. (1996), it was emphasised that even where disciplinary proceedings have been initiated against an employee, his/her employer cannot deny him/her gratuity. The judiciary consistently protects the right to gratuity unless dismissal is based on reasons outlined in the Act.

The point from these judgments is that unless fired under reasons expressly stated in the Payment of Gratuity Act, an employee remains eligible to receive gratuity.

Impact Of Criminal Proceedings And Non-Vacation Of Quarters

Doubt exists as to whether or not an employee could be denied his/her long-service benefits due to involvement in criminal cases or failure to vacate company premises occupied by him/her. Court decisions have elaborated on this aspect too.

Nonetheless, in Travancore Plywood Ind. Ltd. v. Regional Joint Labour Commissioner (1996), it was decided by the court that non-receipt of employers land cannot be used as grounds for retaining the gratuity.

Also, Lt.Col. A.V. Tiwari (Retd.) v The Secretary Ministry Of Welfare, Government Of India (1996) declared that even if employees refuse to leave accommodation provided by employers they should be given their retrenchment benefits including gratuities.

Further on in Rajendra Kumar Nangia v Rashtriya Chemicals & Fertilizers Ltd.(2002), it was also said that the mere pendency of a criminal case will not preclude an employee from receiving his/her dues under the govt scheme. This protection ensures that ongoing legal proceedings do not impede employees from enjoying their normal accretions as a result of the unfair denial of such benefits.

Conditions For Gratuity Forfeiture

The Act and various judgments provide for the fact that only under certain conditions may a worker’s right to receive gratuity be forfeited. These are

Misconduct as defined under section 4(6) leading to the dismissal of an employee.
Willful omission, negligence or riotous conduct demonstrated by the employer.
Before any confiscation is done, the employee is given fair notice and an opportunity to be heard in his or her defence.

The courts in India have taken a similar view. In Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd. v. Pramodini Rohidas Sutar (2009), it was held that a forfeiture of gratuity on grounds of moral turpitude should only be valid if the employee has been convicted of the offence.

Also, in Vijaya Bank v. Sri Mohan Das Ramana Shetty (2009), emphasis was laid that gratuity could not be forfeited unless the respondent had been afforded a hearing.

Employee Rights And Employer Obligations

There is a statutory requirement that employees must receive gratuity after working for no less than five years. The employer is required by law to pay this amount except under certain specified circumstances where there can be a forfeiture of it. Any retention or reduction regarding gratuity payment without following due process provisions amounts to unfairness which can always be contested before court.

Employees, whose gratuities have been unduly held back, can seek redress from courts of law. On many occasions, the courts have said that gratuity cannot be withheld arbitrarily as it is considered one of the retiral benefits.

Conclusion

The forfeiture of gratuity is purely governed by law with clear-cut reasons for non-payment. As such employers must strictly adhere to legal requirements before withholding or forfeiting an employee’s beneficial retirement entitlements. Employees should know these legal safeguards so that their rights are violated not or infringed upon.

You can explore the specific legal provisions related to gratuity forfeiture under Section 4(6) of the Payment of Gratuity Act by following this link Section 4(6) - Payment of Gratuity Act.

Frequently Asked Questions